Looking For A Way Out For The MTA

The past week has been full of headlines about the MTA’s budgets problems. Whether it was the announcement that nearly 1,000 MTA employees will be let go, to a drop in subway ridership (and, hence, fare revenue) for the first time in six years, the MTA’s budget problems continue.

Yet a number of groups and individuals have been offering — and resurrecting — ideas for how the MTA can work to fill its fiscal hole.

The Drum Major Institute released a report entitled “The Urgency of Resurrecting Congestion Pricing in New York.” In it, they argue that congestion pricing, which was promoted by Mayor Bloomberg but defeated by the New York State Assembly in 2008, could close the MTA’s $400 million projected shortfall.

Late last week New York City Public Advocate de Blasio told StreetsBlog he thought setting up tolls along the East River Bridges might be a way to bring extra funds to the agency.

And a week ago Rep. Michael McMahon (D-Staten Island) joined a number of MTA board members in a call for the MTA to use federal stimulus funds to help avert major service disruptions.

However, the ability for these programs to solve the MTA’s problems, let alone get passed, was something policy and labor groups, as well as a former MTA board member, were asked about.

“I think all of them are good options. I’m completely in favor of congestion pricing,” said Jonathan Bowles, Director of the New York City-based think tank Center for an Urban Future. While acknowledging he wasn’t following the details of the MTA’s struggles intensely, Bowles supported much of the program advocated in the Drum Major Institute piece.

However, the political reality — and danger — of championing something as legislative controversial as congestion pricing or bridge tolling was not something he thought many state legislators were willing to take on in an election year.

“I’d be surprised if the legislators outside of Manhattan or even the suburban districts vote right now to include a new–what is perceived as a new levy — on their constituents,” Bowles said. He believed that, out of the three, federal stimulus funds — which other major transit systems have used — was most likely to move forward.

James Parrot, Deputy Director and Chief Economist at the Fiscal Policy Institute, felt it was too soon to begin discussing new revenue streams for the MTA. He believes the payroll tax enacted last year — which the Drum Major Institute cites in its report as falling $700 million short in expected revenues — needs more time to see if it can bring in the money it promised.

“Part of the shortfall might be due to a timing issue regarding the collection of the payroll tax,” Parrot said. He made it clear who he felt should bear the blame for the MTA’s situation.

“Under former Governor Pataki, MTA finances were royally screwed up,” he said. Parrot pointed to the organization’s debt service budget — that money the MTA pays out to cover its debt– which grew by hundreds of millions of dollars thanks, he said, to Pataki tax and budget policies.

“Give George Pataki credit for that,” Parrot added. “He’s responsible for this mess we’re seeing today.”

While she agreed that the MTA’s financial obligations were a major problem facing the agency, Nicole Gelinas, Senior Fellow at the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research, and Contributing Editor to their quarterly magazine, City Journal, felt the issue was the MTA’s labor costs that put it, as she said, “in a constant permanent crisis.”

“We need top to bottom labor reform,” Gelinas said. She also was less than convinced proposals like East River bridge tolling or congestion pricing would live up to expectations. She pointed to the payroll tax shortfalls and wondered if new tolling would deliver as disappointingly.

Jim Gannon, a spokesperson for the Transit Workers Union, which represents thousands of MTA employees, believed the agency’s priorities helped fuel the crisis.

“It’s a crisis of immediacy,” he said. “It’s time to calm down, hold back a little bit on these megaprojects.” He wanted to see a shift in funds from the capital budget, which pays for the MTA’s new projects like the 2nd Avenue subway construction, to the operating budget, which is where the current cuts to subway and bus lines would come from.

Gannon, too, was critical of the MTA’s handling of its debt load. “The operating budget is consistently being handcuffed and burdened with payment to debt service, all of it used for capital projects,” he said.

Regardless of whether or not a proposal like bridge tolls or congestion pricing will make a difference for the MTA, said former board member Barbara Fife, is irrelevant if it can’t get passed in Albany. And the chances of that, she believed, are slim.

“The east river tolls are something almost every mayor has brought up but it is a very tough political issue,” Fife said. “It has been a third rail and it would take a lot of political skill to get support behind that.”

— Colby Hamilton

Posted in News, Politics and MoneyComments Off on Looking For A Way Out For The MTA

The MTA Roundup — Feb. 24

amNY reported yesterday that the MTA’s threat to layoff over 450 station agents could be a power play to get the transit union to agree to a pay freeze. The MTA announced early yesterday that it was planning on laying off over 1,000 workers as it struggles to bridge a $400 million budget gap.

Lt. Gov. Richard Ravitch told the Gotham Gazette yesterday that he does not support Gov. Paterson’s proposed payroll tax increase. The payroll tax on businesses in 12 counties in and around New York City was enacted last year, but has so far failed to raise the funds needed to meet the MTA’s budget needs.

WNYC has a podcast that follows federal stimulus money around the country to see how it impacts transit.

Posted in NewsComments Off on The MTA Roundup — Feb. 24

Countdown Clocks May Be Coming to A Station Near You

The MTA is now testing countdown clocks at various stations around the boroughs. The new countdown clocks were recently unveiled at the 145th Street Station on the ABCD line.

Commuters heading south from the station in Harlem are told how many stations away the next train is by an automated voice through the station’s speaker system. The clocks also tell you how many minutes away the next train is.

The riders we spoke with said the clocks would be nice if they actually worked. Most straphangers agreed that it’s a nice touch but they griped that the clocks are a bit off.

The countdown clocks at the 145th Street Station join 24 clocks already in place along the L line. The MTA says that they plan to have 100 clocks operating in 2010 and that all stations on numbered lines will have the new countdown clocks by the end of 2011.

Take a look at this video to see what straphangers at the 145th Street Station had to say about the new clocks.

–Walter Smith-Randolph

Posted in News2 Comments

Smile! If You’re On the E Train, You May Be On Camera

The MTA began a pilot program testing surveillance cameras onboard the E-train yesterday.

Four cars of the ten car train are now equipped with video cameras that will record your every move while onboard the train. The MTA says the cameras are designed to be unobtrusive. They also say that a video surveillance decal will be visible to alert passengers that they are being videotaped.

At the end of the 12-month testing period, the closed circuit television system will be evaluated to determine if NYC Transit will install more cameras onboard other trains.

The NY Post has exclusive video and photos of the new surveillance system.

Posted in News1 Comment

MTA to Lay Off Hundreds of Station Agents

The Metropolitan Transportation Authority is expected to announce today that they will lay off hundreds of subway station agents.

Subway station agents provide customer information, sell Metrocards, and assist commuters at various stations throughout the subway system.

The layoffs come after the MTA began to phase out station agents who do not handle money last September.

According to The New York Times, the MTA planned to allow the station agents to retire and that the cuts will save $50 million. amNewYork reports that the MTA will boot the workers by this summer.

The MTA has a $400 million deficit and is trying to bridge the gap in their budget. They have announced the elimination of several bus lines, two train lines, and free Metrocards for students. Public hearings for the proposed cuts are set to begin on March 1.

Posted in News, Politics and Money1 Comment

SI Ferry Bucks the Trend

While the rest of New York City’s transit system has seen a decline in ridership, the State Island ferry — NYC’s cheapest cruise — has seen a rise in ridership, the SI Advance reports. From the article:

The ferry has seen a 10 percent rise in riders over the past three years, as the flagging economy drove many budget-conscious commuters off increasingly expensive express buses and onto the free orange boat to Manhattan.

Of course, droves of new riders have created some drawbacks: apparently catching a power nap or purchasing a tall boy for the ride home is getting next to impossible.

Posted in CommutersComments Off on SI Ferry Bucks the Trend

NYC Transit Chief Vows Repairs

NYC Transit Chief Thomas Prendergrast

NYC Transit President Thomas Prendergast is sending tradesmen and workers to fix 8 subway stations in four boroughs, according to the Daily News.  All stations in question have benefited from major renovations in recent years, but were denied the follow-up care needed to keep them in ship-shape.

The president, who started his job in December, is now ready to improve the system despite the looming budget shortfalls.

He also vows to improve rush-hour service on the Lexington Avenue line.

Posted in News, Politics and MoneyComments Off on NYC Transit Chief Vows Repairs

VIDEO: Subway Slump

Subway and bus ridership dropped in 2009, for the first time in six years, according to the New York Times. Media reports are suggesting the loss is due to the recession.

But riders that we spoke to at the 72nd Street station say that’s not the only reason. Columbia student Tyler Kim says he’s been taking taxis more often because he doesn’t feel safe on the train at night.

Still, most riders say they’re sticking with the MTA. In New York City, what choice do you have?

Take a look at what riders told us turns them off about the tracks and what keeps them coming back. Then let us know what you think about the system.

– Simone Sebastian

Posted in Commuters, News3 Comments

The MTA Roundup

Need to know what’s been happening on the tracks for the past week? Here’s your roundup of the latest MTA news:

Just as we were getting over that extra quarter, a new report says that the MTA will have to hike the price per ride to $2.75 to help close its budget shortfall, according to wpix.com.

Proof that it’s never a good idea to stand close to that yellow platform line: One 18-year-old fell into the tracks after she suddenly got dizzy on an N-train platform last week. Most people in the station were stunned still, according to the guy who eventually saved her.

It’s an NYPD campaign we thought we could all get behind. But now the New York Post is reporting that police are ticketing people for taking up more than one seat in empty subway cars. Tickets for the crime saw a 17 percent jump between 2008 and 2009, according to the Gothamist.

And don’t forget, the public hearings on the MTA’s proposed budget cuts start a week from today. You can get a list of the times and places here.

– Simone Sebastian

Posted in NewsComments Off on The MTA Roundup

Then why are the trains still so crowded?

The MTA released its ridership figures for 2009 yesterday.  Apparently there were over 63 million fewer rides on the system than in 2008.  The system total is still a respectable 2.31 billion, but it represents the first annual drop since 2003.

Fault is, of course, the great recession and the effect job-loss has on the need to use the train every day.

The diminishing ridership comes in the face of budget shortfalls and service cuts.

Still, anyone standing on overcrowded platforms between 7 AM and 9 AM is forgiven for wondering how those 63 million extra passengers fit on to the already overcrowded trains.

Check out NY1 for a news clip.

Posted in Commuters, NewsComments Off on Then why are the trains still so crowded?