A woman 32 weeks pregnant was fined $75 for moving between cars on a No. 1 train stopped at a Times Square station earlier this month. She told the New York Post that she was looking for a seat on a jam-packed train during her afternoon commute. Her story begged the question: why is a pregnant woman looking for a seat?

NYCTracks.com braved the crowds of the Times Square evening commute to find out who subway riders will and won’t stand up for. Do young children get precedence overly elderly train riders? What about pregnant women? Do they get the seat instead of the guy carrying two fists full of shopping bags? And should a young man give his seat up to a woman in heels at the end of the work day?

Almost everyone we talked to said they regularly stood up for fellow subway riders in need. But those needy travelers tell a different story. When they board the train, suddenly everyone is sleeping. Hmmmm….

– Simone Sebastian